Last week, I was out in Long Island scouting around Jericho Turnpike, which, if you’ve never had the pleasure of driving, is one of those hellish, strip mall-lined highways with traffic lights that are perfectly synchronized to make your travel time as long as possible.

MC (01)

As I was driving, I happened to notice a McDonalds sign up ahead. Nothing too special about that, except where the McDonalds should have been, there seemed to be a big white mansion. Maybe it was around back or something?

MC (03)

And then I realized…

MC (04)

The mansion was the McDonalds.

MC (05)

Holy. Crap.

MC (06)

This 100+ year old Georgian mansion is indeed a McDonalds, and while well known to locals, it totally caught me by surprise. I practically expected a maitre d’ to greet me as I went inside.

MC (07)

Known as the Denton House, its bones date back to 1795, when it was constructed as a farm house by one Joseph Denton, a descendent of the founder of the village of Hempstead. In 1860, it was given a Georgian makeover, complete with gingerbread ornamentation, and throughout the 1900’s, found commercial use as a funeral home and a series of restaurants.

By 1986, it was abandoned and on the verge of falling down.

hist2

McDonalds purchased the property with the intention of tearing it down and replacing it with a standard McDonald’s restaurant. Thank God for the citizens of the New Hyde Park, who worked to secure landmark status for the building in 1987.

McDonald’s had no choice but to restore the property and work within the parameters of the landmarks commission, which ultimately resulted in their most beautiful restaurant in America (if you know of a better example, please let me know).

MC (21)

It was decided to restore the property to its 1926 appearance, based on an old photograph. Opened in the early 1990’s, the house remains in fantastic shape to this day.

MC (08)

One of the mansion’s most striking aspects is its beautiful glassed-in veranda…

MC (09)

…which offers a pretty unique McDonald’s eating experience (how cool would it be if it was actually open, or covered by screens?).

MC (20)

But the details continue around on its eastern side…

MC (10)

…from its shuttered windows and brick chimneys to its eaves dripping with gingerbread ornamentation:

MC (11)

The western half is equally stately…

MC (13)

…though, er, methinks the drive-through might not be original to the Denton farmhouse:

MC (15)

But had someone showed me this picture, I would have NEVER guessed it was a McDonald’s.

MC (15a)

Unfortunately, the inside has been totally gutted and redone without much inspiration.

MC (16)

Still, it is far more unique than your typical McDonald’s, with a grand staircase leading to an upstairs dining area.

MC (17)

Also, there’s something fascinating about being in an enormous open-air mansion, and I definitely appreciate how the roof has been revealed.

MC (19)

Almost as an afterthought, the small ordering area is nestled to one side:

MC (18)

I love the New Hyde Park McDonald’s, if for no better reason than how clearly it makes the argument for historic preservation. We can live in a world of this…

McDonald's Restaurant, Miles City

…or this:

MC (06)

Really don’t have anything else to add.

-SCOUT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. K Avatar
    K

    As with the McDonalds that was featured, the community in Mattituck fought McDonalds until they got what they wanted. I don’t remember, but I believe the one in Mattituck has very limited signage as well. If there is a sign, it’s probably waist high.

  2. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Next time on LI dont take Sunrise or the LIE. Jump on the SSP or NSP parkways they are much more prettier to drive on.

    1. K Avatar
      K

      Yes, they are prettier roads. But as their name implies, “Park”ways, they were intended for “Sunday Drivers” . The lanes are narrow and the curves in the road were not intended for cars traveling at 60 +/- mph. I always found it interesting the number of parks and park vestiges that can still be found and ino use along most of the parkways Robert Moses built in NY.

      1. Chris Avatar
        Chris

        You are correct, but on a nice Saturday or Sunday morning in the spring or summer it sure is pretty.

  3. Andrej Avatar
    Andrej

    Whatever Mary, walk to McDonalds!!!

  4. Pamela Avatar

    Fantastic pictures as always. I recently visited Belfast , Ireland and came across the most beautiful building that has been converted into a Tescos supermarket – I have added a picture to my blog – http://ellaspencilsandpens.blogspot.co.uk/2012/05/pretty-places.html

    1. Stewart Avatar
      Stewart

      Sorry to be pedantic, but the Irish won’t thank you for saying Belfast is in Ireland. It’s in Northern Ireland. That’s a different country entirely 😉

  5. Lisa Avatar
    Lisa

    Rothenburg ob der Tauber, in Germany, has a McDonald’s very discretely tucked into a 16th century stone building on the main Market Plaza. Small sign, no ads in the windows, you have to really look to find it. No pics tho, sorry!

  6. Emilio Avatar
    Emilio

    What’s the exact address?

  7. Brian Westbye Avatar

    Glad to see Freeport (and the Ellsworth Subway) getting some love! Although neither are as grandiose as the one McD’s in this post.

  8. Prewar Walt Avatar
    Prewar Walt

    If you don’t like Jericho Turnpike to drive down you will like Hempstead Turnpike even less – it is twice as bad. Yes, this structure was at one time the Dallas Rib restaurant. The interior was so chopped up over the years it couldn’t be restored. It took about 2 + years to bring the building back and a lot of $. This building is on the north side of Jericho Tpke just west of Denton Avenue.

  9. Matthew Wilber Avatar

    Thank you so much for posting this. I went to that McDonalds a few times when I was a kid and it always stood out in my memory. Over the years, I lost track of it and could never remember where exactly it was. I was beginning to doubt my memory. Next time I’m up in NY I’m going to take my kids there.

  10. Bill Avatar
    Bill

    This was billed as the Most Magnificent when it was built in the early 90’s

    http://goo.gl/maps/oaVX

  11. Rosemary Avatar
    Rosemary

    I drove by this McDonalds with my family last weekend when we were in NY for a wedding, and we commented on how unique it was. Kind of funny to see it pop on here now a week later!

  12. RAYMOND HOLMES Avatar
    RAYMOND HOLMES

    It really outdoes the well-known “McDonald House”…I know it’s for a good cause.

    So happy the ‘GOOD AMERICANS’ have reached your $15,000 goal.

    I have friends in that area and hope they have or are frequenting your WONDERFUL house.

  13. Lexi Y. Avatar
    Lexi Y.

    The Lake Forest, IL McDonald’s is also quite beautiful. Not as much as this one, but it might be second on the list. It was designed to look like a barn, and it is actually very beautiful and different.

  14. Ryan Avatar
    Ryan

    i’m surprised Jericho Tpk is discribed as “strip mall-lined highways with traffic lights that are perfectly synchronized to make your travel time as long as possible.” There are only a few strip malls along Jericho in New Hyde Park and continuing west towards Queens. Also “highway”? The speed limit is between 30 and 40 mph. If you want to put that type of description on a road, please drive down Hempstead Turnpike, especially in Levittown. It is exactly what not to do to create a pedestrian-friendly environment. It was also named one of the most deadliest roads on Long Island. Please do not put that type of demeaning description in such a great town.

  15. Miko Avatar
    Miko

    Years ago the Studabaker Mansion near or in South Bend, Indiana, had a wonderful restaraunt that served the most delicious Sunday brunch. Don’t know if they’re still in business…but the mansion was amazingly beautiful! (Please excuse misspellings! No spell check available.)

  16. Ann Avatar
    Ann

    I was prepared to hate this, but actually by the end, I had decided it was better than having the mansion torn down!

  17. Judy Avatar
    Judy

    I don’t eat at McDonald’s, but this is beautiful. Thank you for sharing.

  18. Christine Avatar
    Christine

    I have lived in New Hyde Park all my life and was at this McDonald’s the day it opened!!! To tell you the truth, The Denton House never looked better (except maybe in its heyday of course). Thank you for writing about this beautiful McDonald’s – even if you called Jericho “hellish!”

  19. Pat Avatar
    Pat

    thank you for your comments. my husband and I were the people who submitted the historic preservation application. it took a lot of hard work and support to accomplish this but it was well worth it. it is just sad that many of the people who jumped on the bandwagon after the fact actually opposed saving the building and refused to support us. a wonderful Garden City Park historian gave us the background we were unable to find in the library. people from different states who had similar situations also gave us encouragement. we are glad the Denton house still stands and that people passing do give pause and admire it.

    1. Mary Lou Avatar
      Mary Lou

      Thank you so much for submitting the paperwork that brought about the saving of this building. My grandfather Luigi Montaruli owned a restaurant there in the 50″s. I along with many of my other family members lived upstairs and all worked in the restaurant. It is awesome to see this building preserved. Thank you for caring about the history of your community. I also remember Barton’s Stadium on the other side of Jericho Turnpike; most likely torn down many years ago.