The other day, I was scouting the steps of the New York Public Library main branch. I’ve had to do this assignment a million times over the years for various movies and TV shows that want to shoot at the world’s most famous library, and I began thinking how sad it was to know a location so well that there were no surprises left to find.

01

As I was taking the pictures, I happened to zoom in on this row of statues over the main entrance:

02

Nothing really stood out about them…

03

Just your run-of-the-mill toga-clad statuary, all looking appropriately deep in thought:

04

I was about to move on when one of the statues caught my eye: a woman, who resembled all the others except for one very unusual feature…

05

She was holding a decapitated head.

06

OK, I’ve been to the New York Public Library a million times over the years, and I’ve NEVER noticed this. Who is she, and why does she look so angry? And who was the bodyless man?

07

I couldn’t find the answer anywhere online (everyone just writes about the lions) so I wrote to the NYPL. It turns out that is the personification of Drama, as sculpted by Paul Wayland Bartlett. She is joined on both sides by fellow “attic sculptures” representing (from left to right) History, Romance, Religion, Poetry, and Philosophy.

08

So does that mean it’s just a Tragedy mask? That would make sense, but tell me I’m wrong in thinking that looks like she’s holding a head by the hair. Is there a particular work this was inspired by?

Whatever the answer might be, finding the statue of a woman holding a decapitated head on the New York Public Library is a really great reminder for the New Year that, no matter how well you think you know New York, there are ALWAYS surprises to be found.

-SCOUT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Cully Avatar
    Cully

    It’s more likely intended to be a mask. We are talking classical drama here, Greek style, where everyone was masked. You know, the whole Comedy/Tragedy thing that has been passed down and now adorns every High School drama club logo?

  2. Liam Avatar
    Liam

    Maybe it’s Judith holding the head of Holofernes?
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Judith

  3. Cully Avatar
    Cully

    Looking closer at it, I think the object in her left hand is ALSO a mask, you can see an eye and nose to the right of her wrist, and I think that is the mask’s beard extending below her arm. Masks.

    1. Scout Avatar

      Ha, I saw that too, but I think it’s just an illusion from what she’s really doing, bunching her robe together.

      1. Lifeboatb Avatar
        Lifeboatb

        As other people have said below, it’s another mask; good eye, Cully!

  4. Sandy Conley Avatar
    Sandy Conley

    Maybe she’s the woman in The Bacchae (Agave?) who yanked off her son’s head in a Dionysian frenzy, thinking it was a mountain lion?

  5. Phil Avatar

    looks like a classical judith pose to me.

  6. Perkins Avatar
    Perkins

    Perhaps these are the four muses, and that is the head of Orpheus.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orpheus

  7. JenW Avatar
    JenW

    I don’t know. I think @Cully was on to something. I think that’s a mask in her left hand, too.

  8. Chris Albertson Avatar

    It would never have occurred to me that this was anything but a mask. I love your scouting reports, but I think this one was a bit of a stretch.

  9. Susanne Avatar
    Susanne

    Definitely a mask. And I agree with @Cully about the second one. An antique representation can be found here: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ny_Carlsberg_Glyptothek_-_Melpomene.jpg, and if you look at Wikimedia’s Greek and Roman theater masks category, there are more.

  10. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    looks like the head of Medusa from the 1980’s “Clash of the Titans” movie. Incredible find!

  11. Heshy Avatar
    Heshy

    It’s most likely SALOME, from the play by Oscar Wilde. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salome_(play)

    1. crumpet Avatar
      crumpet

      nope. she got the head of John the Baptist on a plate. and she kissed him.

  12. Tim H Avatar
    Tim H

    Very interesting. In a slightly related matter — and just a block away at 285 Madison Avenue — exists a treasure trove of smaller figures, frozen in time on the side of the building. (Please cut-and-paste this URL if it is not a “live” link:
    http://ephemeralnewyork.wordpress.com/tag/285-madison-avenue/ )

    1. Dave Avatar
      Dave

      When I lived in Murray Hill I’d pass this one frequently when walking towards Bryant Park. Great building…

  13. Courtney Avatar
    Courtney

    The idea that it’s the personification of drama is interesting…has anyone thought that it might be Judith holding the head of Holofernes? That’s a pretty common theme in western art…

  14. Peter Avatar

    Actually, the sculptor was inspired by the movie Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia.

  15. Ryan Avatar
    Ryan

    That book he returned must have been really overdue. 😉

  16. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    You just gave me a reason to go visit that library branch. I can’t wait to share this creepy find with my friends.

  17. Theo Avatar
    Theo

    Isn’t it obvious? That’s the head librarian.

    1. Old Skool Avatar
      Old Skool

      Dude, I love that. Great reply.

  18. Tim H Avatar
    Tim H

    …or, Charles Taylor, the former Head Liberian
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Taylor_(Liberian_politician)

  19. glenn allen Avatar
    glenn allen

    I was looking for a close-up of the guy to her left – Philosophy, I guess?

  20. Erin Avatar
    Erin

    The two bearded old men represent History and Philosophy. The two pairs of female figures in between represent Romance and Religion, Poetry and Drama. So the Drama figure with the “head” is actually holding a theater mask. The pieces were sculpted by Paul Bartlett and carved by the Piccirilli Brothers, who also carved the huge seated Lincoln at the Lincoln Memorial in D.C.

    1. Lifeboatb Avatar
      Lifeboatb

      And here’s a lovely portrait of sculptor Paul Bartlett by Charles Sprague Pearce: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Pearce_Bartlett.jpg
      I’ve known about this portrait for a long time, but didn’t know much about the work the subject had done; it was fun to find out some of it is on this famous library (thanks, Erin!).